Why Incumbents Keep Winning Elections and What It Says About Trust in Leadership

Every election season across the United States, one fact consistently stands out. The majority of incumbents, the leaders already serving in office, win reelection and continue their work in public service. This is not simply a political quirk but a well-documented reality known as the incumbency advantage. It plays a significant role in shaping the outcomes of elections, from congressional races in Washington to city and county contests in communities like Eagle Pass and Maverick County.

The data tells the story clearly. In the 2024 general election, about 95 percent of incumbents who ran for reelection retained their seats (Ballotpedia, 2024). In 2022, the figure was nearly the same at 94 percent (Ballotpedia, 2022). Members of the U.S. House of Representatives have consistently won reelection at rates above 90 percent (OpenSecrets, 2024). Governors show a similar pattern, with roughly 74.6 percent winning reelection since 1948 and nearly 89.5 percent doing so in recent years (Rutgers University, 2024). These numbers reveal a broader truth about how voters think. People often turn to what they know and trust, especially when it comes to leadership.

READ: Two Women Arrested in Zavala County After Traffic Stop Reveals Stolen Dodge Charger

There are many reasons incumbents hold this advantage, and most of them are rooted in the relationship between officials and the communities they serve. Name recognition plays a major role. Voters are more likely to support someone they are already familiar with, especially if that leader has shown up for their community. Over time, public officials build credibility by attending local events, helping residents navigate services, and advocating for resources. That visibility creates a sense of stability and confidence, qualities voters often value when choosing who should lead them.

Experience is another powerful factor. Incumbents have spent time learning the complexities of government, building relationships, and understanding the needs of their districts. They know how to secure funding, deliver infrastructure projects, and move legislation forward. These are skills that often take years to develop. Many voters see this experience as a strength, believing that continuity helps keep local projects on track and ensures their voices are heard.

Financial support also plays a part. Officeholders usually have well-established networks of supporters and donors who trust their leadership and want to see their work continue. That backing allows incumbents to reach more voters, share their accomplishments, and communicate their plans for the future (OpenSecrets, 2024). This does not just give them a strategic advantage. It also signals that their work has earned confidence from individuals, businesses, and organizations invested in their success.

READ: Sul Ross State University Purchases 43 Acres in Eagle Pass for International Campus

There is also a deeper psychological element at work. People are naturally drawn to familiarity, especially when it comes to decision-making that affects their lives. Choosing an incumbent can feel like choosing security, someone whose leadership style, priorities, and track record are already known. Challengers, on the other hand, must not only present new ideas but also convince voters to trust them with the responsibility of governing. That is often a difficult task when the incumbent has already built a foundation of trust.

None of this means that change never happens. Scandals, shifting public priorities, or political movements can lead voters to choose a new direction. Over longer periods, turnover still occurs. Research from the Pew Research Center shows that about 69 percent of House seats and 62 percent of Senate seats change hands over a 12-year period (Pew Research Center, 2022). But more often than not, the public chooses to stay with the leaders they know, a decision that reflects faith in their experience and a desire for continuity.

In local communities like Eagle Pass and Maverick County, this trust-based dynamic is even more pronounced. Residents often know their leaders personally, have seen their work firsthand, or benefited from decisions made during their time in office. Those personal connections, combined with a track record of service, make a strong case for reelection.

READ: Uvalde Woman Aide to Congressman Tony Gonzales Died After Dousing Herself in Gasoline

Understanding why incumbents win so often is less about political strategy and more about human behavior. Voters tend to reward those who have delivered for their communities, who have earned their trust, and who represent stability in a constantly changing world. This does not mean challengers cannot succeed, but it does mean that incumbents who continue to serve with integrity and dedication often find their efforts recognized at the ballot box.

About The Author